We Came As Romans is a band that I have been following now for almost a year. I first heard a few songs from their last ep "Dreams" and knew that this band would be making noise in the near future. WCAR was signed to Equal Vision Records in April of 2009 and quite frankly I thought this was a great move for both parties. EV has been a great label for Post-hardcore bands such as Coheed and Cambria, Chiodos, Pierce The Veil and Sky Eats Airplane just to name a few. "To Plant A Seed" was recorded at Joey Sturgis's Foundation Recording Studio. Sturgis is by far my favorite producer right now because of his work with many Rise Records bands and his ability to recognize a bands vision for their album."To Plant A Seed" has very much the same sound and feel as their previous EP "Dreams". WCAR incorporates a lot of different parts in their songs. When looking at a lot of the new wave screamo bands, you can pretty much throw concrete song structure out the window. This holds true for We Came As Romans new album. That's not to say it's a bad thing because each song keeps you guessing. One minute you are hearing break downs and bass drops and the next minute the song can go into an emotional, digital, synth driven part. Some people might not like that style of songwriting but I think that it's good to hear music that takes you on a ride so to speak. Music has become so predictable and I like the fact that bands are taking a different approach to writing their songs.
We Came As Romans have found their niche in the post-hardcore, screamo genre. Kyle Pavone (vocals, keys) takes a more orchestral approach to the synth parts in the songs. You can see a lot of influence from fellow Michigan band Chiodos. His high pitched singing rivals any singer in the genre. David Stephens (vocals) hones in on a throaty mid-range metal scream. The contrasting vocal styles used on this album are compared to the likes of bands such as Underoath, The Devil Wears Prada and Attack Attack.
Although We Came As Romans definitely hit the nail on the head stylistically (as far as what's going on right now in the Post-hardcore, Screamo genre) there are a few issues I have with this album personally. For instance, although I like this bands sound I don't see a lot of growth in their new songs. When comparing the EP to the LP I didn't see the leaps and bounds I expected to hear. That being said, these guys are still young and this is their first stab at a LP. Im looking forward to when they release future albums to see if they step into their own as opposed to mimicking what's going on right now in their genre.
Like many of the bands going the screamo, synth route, WCAR uses a lot of tempo changes in their songs. That's cool in stuff and I understand the reasoning behind that (randomly slowing down the tempo to increase the brutality of breakdowns) but the transitions between parts aren't defined. The problem I have with it is you can hear the speed of the song randomly change without warning. Although I like many of the individual sections of the songs, sometimes the transitions seemed forced as if they didn't know how to fit the puzzle pieces together.
In conclusion, this album is a strong first release for this band. If you have never heard We Came As Romans and you like screamo music there is a good chance you will enjoy this album. They are at the forefront of what's "in" right now. Take the album for what it is and we will see what they can come up with next.
-7 of 10
Give the album a listen for yourself: DOWNLOAD